Discussion about this post

User's avatar
rob's avatar

great article! many are too afraid to support those who fight back against those who attack and oppress them because, in their eyes, it no longer makes them the "perfect" victims whose martyrdom is the price of some mythical innocence. decolonial struggle is born out of the extreme violence of imperialism, which is never "clean" or "pure" in the way overly simplistic good vs evil narratives are created to be. all colonial subjects have a right to violence and all nations deserve the same right to imperfection that the rest of the world is given (it's also much more difficult to focus on these things when you're under constant economic and literal warfare by the richest and most violent country on earth), and policing their struggle from across the world is a transparent demonstration of both ones ignorance and arrogance.

Shah Jawad's avatar

What this misses is that Iran is an imperialist force just like America and Israel. It has proxies like Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Syria, the Houthis in Yemen and on and on. It's not the on your face type American imperialism but it is still imperialism.

This is not an innocent girl in school fighting a bully. It's an evil weak bully fighting an evil strong bully.

I've heard people argue that Iran's proxies are 'resistance', and I find it to be nonsensical. Yes, Iran's official foreign policy is 'defensive' but so is America's, with propaganda words like 'deterrence' and 'national security.' Imperialism disguised as 'defense' has been around since the Roman empire.

I do support Iran's right to defend itself and it absolutely should. Otherwise, it's just a free pass for the US and Israel to do whatever the hell they want. If the weak bully teaches the strong bully a lesson that's good, but I'm not going to cheer for them 24/7.

The long-term solution to imperialism is a global police system. The UN tried to fill that role after the second world war. It has succeeded somewhat; it's definitely been better than the league of nations. But for the most part it has failed.

What I'm saying is that we need an organization that has UN like goals but actually gets things down. Otherwise, geopolitics will forever boil down to a depressing bloodbath of imperialists against imperialists.

28 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?